Comments on Copyright

Judge Charlton’s judgement in the EMI and Ors -v- UPC case has provoked a number of comments.

For the moment, I’d recommend Rossa McMahon’s post Strike One? as the quickest and most painless path in to the issues at the heart of the matter.

More later, if permitted by circumstance.

UPDATE: I should add that Judge Charlton’s judgement is a most eloquent argument in favour of Irish Courts welcoming amicus briefs.

As the judge says himself, it was the lack of a contradictor- a shortage of alternative views being voiced- which led him to err in the earlier EMI and Ors -v- Eircom case.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.